The best is yet to come
OK
Log out of UNA?
Log out
Cancel
Revolutionizing Immigration with AI
My Appointments
Welcome to UNA
Unconstitutional Clause in Canada's Citizenship Act Amendment: Court Grants Another Extension Until November 20

Canada's Ontario Superior Court issued a new ruling on April 22, 2025, further extending the federal government's deadline to amend the "First Generation Limit" (FGL) clause in the Citizenship Act concerning the acquisition of citizenship by descent. The new deadline has now been set for November 20, 2025.

Background of the Dispute: The Unconstitutional "First Generation Limit"

Under the current provisions of the Canadian Citizenship Act, if a Canadian citizen has children born abroad, these children can typically automatically acquire Canadian citizenship by descent, even if they are born outside Canada. However, the "First Generation Limit" clause introduced in 2009 changed this rule. The clause stipulates that if a child of a Canadian citizen is born abroad, and that Canadian citizen themselves obtained their citizenship "by descent" (i.e., not born in Canada or naturalized), then their child born abroad cannot automatically acquire Canadian citizenship by descent. This is what is known as the "First Generation Limit."

This "First Generation Limit" clause was ruled unconstitutional by the Ontario Superior Court in December 2023, as it was deemed to infringe upon rights guaranteed by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. At that time, the court ordered the federal government to complete legislative amendments within six months.

Legislative Process and Temporary Measures

The federal government chose not to appeal the unconstitutional ruling and introduced Bill C-71 in May 2024, attempting to address the issue by establishing a "Substantial Connection" test – requiring Canadian citizen parents of children born abroad to have resided in Canada for at least three years before the child's birth or adoption. However, Bill C-71 failed to pass and automatically lapsed when Parliament adjourned on January 6, 2025. Prior to this, the court had already granted four extensions to the amendment deadline, the most recent of which extended it to April 25, 2025.

Following the lapse of Bill C-71, the federal government introduced temporary measures on March 13, 2025, allowing individuals affected by the "First Generation Limit" to apply for a discretionary grant of citizenship. Simultaneously, the government requested the court to extend the amendment deadline by a significant 12 months, until March 20, 2026.

Court's Stance and Future Challenges

However, in her ruling issued on April 22, Justice Jasmine Akbarali of the Ontario Superior Court, while approving the extension request, only extended the deadline until November 20, 2025, nearly four months shorter than the government's request. This means that the new Canadian Parliament, to be formed after the election scheduled for April 28, will have approximately eight months to address this urgent legislative task.

Justice Akbarali wrote in her ruling that despite the continued delay causing ongoing hardship for rights holders affected by the "First Generation Limit," she chose to grant the extension considering the complexity of citizenship legislation and the potential negative impact on the public interest if the declaration of unconstitutionality took effect without substitute legislation. However, she also emphasized that "Rights holders should not be forced indefinitely to bear the effects of an unconstitutional law" and that "the public is entitled to expect Parliament to fulfill its legislative responsibilities and pass legislation." The judge explicitly stated her hope that "the party that forms government, if it chooses to prioritize this legislation, should be able to pass remedial legislation within this timeframe."

If the federal government fails to pass the legislative amendment by the new deadline, and the court does not grant further extensions, the court may directly strike down or limit the unconstitutional parts of the Citizenship Act, rendering them ineffective.

Key Timelines Related to this Amendment Process:

DateEvent Description
April 17, 2009First Generation Limit introduced into the Citizenship Act; second generation and subsequent generations born abroad cannot inherit citizenship by descent.
December 19, 2023Ontario Superior Court rules First Generation Limit unconstitutional, first ordered a six-month period for amendment.
May 23, 2024Federal government introduces Bill C-71, establishing a "Substantial Connection" exception test.
January 6, 2025Parliament adjourns, Bill C-71 lapses.
March 13, 2025Temporary discretionary citizenship grant measures introduced, and application filed to extend the amendment deadline to March 20, 2026.
April 22, 2025Ontario Superior Court extends the final legislative deadline to November 20, 2025.

Subsequent Observation:

As Canada is set to hold its election on April 28, the formation of the new government and the setting of its legislative agenda will determine whether this pending citizenship legislation can be passed. If the statutory window is missed again, the "Lost Canadians" issue could remain unresolved for a long time, and the discretionary policy without legislative backing will struggle to provide predictable citizenship assurance for the new generation born abroad. In the coming months, the interplay between Canadian immigration policy and parliamentary efficiency will continue to affect the fate of tens of thousands of families.

加拿大移民语言测试添新选项 托福Essentials将被纳入永久居民申请
Canada to Add New Language Test Option for Immigration; TOEFL Essentials to be Accepted for Permanent Residence Applications
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) has confirmed it will begin accepting a new English language test, the TOEFL Essentials, for its economic permanent residence programs. Once implemented, this will provide applicants with a fourth option for proving English proficiency, alongside the existing IELTS, CELPIP, and PTE Core tests. The Educational Testing Service (ETS), the organization behind the test, is collaborating with IRCC on the final details, and the official start date and available test locations will be announced upon confirmation.
08/23/2025
加拿大大西洋移民计划2025年最新动向:各省聚焦重点行业与岗位
Canada's Atlantic Immigration Program: 2025 Updates See Provinces Prioritize Key Sectors and Occupations
In 2025, Canada's Atlantic Immigration Program (AIP) is entering a new strategic phase due to adjusted federal immigration allocations. To manage reduced quotas, the four Atlantic provinces are concentrating their resources on key sectors vital to their local economies. Healthcare, construction, and information technology have become focal points for attracting talent. This report provides an in-depth analysis of the latest priority sectors and occupations for each province, examines the alternative pathways available in New Brunswick following its AIP pause, and offers authoritative guidance for applicants planning to immigrate through this program in 2025.
08/21/2025
加拿大快速通道移民系统最新抽签,向医疗保健行业候选人发出2500份邀请
Canada's Express Entry System Issues 2,500 Invitations to Healthcare Candidates in Latest Draw
On August 19, 2025, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) conducted a new round of targeted draws through the Express Entry system. This draw specifically invited candidates in the healthcare and social services category, issuing 2,500 Invitations to Apply (ITAs). To be eligible, candidates needed a minimum Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) score of 470. This draw highlights Canada's continued emphasis on attracting professionals in the healthcare sector.
08/20/2025
加拿大快速通道最新抽签:省提名分数线飙升至800分
Canada's Latest Express Entry Draw Sees PNP Score Requirement Hit 800
On August 18, 2025, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) conducted a new Express Entry draw, specifically targeting candidates in the Provincial Nominee Program (PNP). The draw issued 192 Invitations to Apply (ITAs) for permanent residence, with a minimum Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) score requirement of 800. This score marks the second-highest of the year, reaffirming the central role of PNPs in Canada's immigration system.
08/19/2025
魁北克PSTQ移民项目扩大邀请范围:首次向中等及体力技能类别发出273份邀请
Quebec Expands PSTQ Invitations, Issuing 273 ITAs in First-Ever Draw for Intermediate and Manual Skills Stream
On July 31, 2025, Quebec’s Ministry of Immigration, Francization and Integration (MIFI) issued 273 invitations to apply for permanent selection through its Skilled Worker Selection Program (PSTQ). This draw is particularly significant as it is the first time the province has specifically targeted candidates under the "Intermediate and Manual Skills" stream, marking a steady expansion of the program's scope. The initiative aims to provide an immigration pathway for workers already in Quebec who possess specific work experience and French-language skills, in order to address labor shortages in various regions of the province.
08/18/2025
超级签证:加拿大父母及祖父母团聚移民的“快车道”与替代方案
Super Visa: Canada's 'Fast Track' Alternative for Parent and Grandparent Reunification
For many families hoping to reunite with parents or grandparents in Canada, the limited lottery for the Parents and Grandparents Program (PGP) presents a significant hurdle. This article provides an in-depth analysis of Canada's Super Visa program, which serves as an attractive alternative by offering a long-term visitor visa with year-round applications. The report details the core differences between the Super Visa and the PGP, outlines eligibility criteria and application procedures, and offers professional strategies to address common reasons for refusal, helping applicants increase their chances of success.
08/17/2025
加拿大省提名移民项目新动向:多省发布定向邀请,聚焦特定行业与战略人才
New Trends in Canada's Provincial Nominee Programs: Multiple Provinces Issue Targeted Invitations, Focusing on Key Sectors and Strategic Talent
Recent Provincial Nominee Program (PNP) draws across Canada reveal a growing trend towards highly targeted invitations for specific industries and communities. Manitoba issued a small number of high-scoring invitations through a strategic initiative; Alberta focused on construction and tech workers with two targeted, low-score draws; and Newfoundland and Labrador invited nearly 400 candidates through its provincial and Atlantic programs. These actions underscore a nationwide shift towards using immigration to precisely fill specific economic and community needs.
08/15/2025
加拿大“快速通道”移民或迎重大调整:拟增设三大新职业类别,吸纳全球顶尖人才
Canada's Express Entry May See Major Overhaul: Three New Occupational Categories Proposed to Attract Global Top Talent
The Canadian federal government is contemplating a significant reform of its flagship immigration program, Express Entry, by proposing three new selection categories for 2026 targeting senior managers, scientists and researchers, and military personnel. The move aims to more strategically attract top-tier talent capable of driving Canada's economic growth, enhancing its global competitiveness, and supporting national security. The proposal is now open for public consultation until September 3, 2025. These adjustments not only signal a shift in Canada's future immigration strategy but could also have far-reaching implications for the study choices and post-graduation career paths of international students.
08/15/2025
加拿大快速通道移民政策重大调整:2025年8月起须预先完成体检
Major Overhaul to Canada's Express Entry: Upfront Medical Exams Mandatory from August 21, 2025
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) has announced a pivotal change to its Express Entry system. Effective August 21, 2025, all candidates applying for permanent residence through this stream will be required to complete their Immigration Medical Exam (IME) before submitting their application. This marks a significant shift from the current "apply-then-test" model to a new "upfront medical" protocol, directly impacting future applicants' timelines and preparatory strategies.
08/13/2025
草原省份强势崛起!2025加拿大移民就业最新指南:萨斯卡通、卡尔加里、里贾纳位列三甲
Prairie Provinces Surge! 2025 Guide to Immigrant Jobs in Canada: Saskatoon, Calgary, and Regina Claim Top Spots
According to the latest BMO Labour Market Report Card released on July 11, 2025, the landscape for immigrant employment in Canada is undergoing a significant transformation. Saskatoon, Calgary, and Regina have emerged as the top three cities for newcomers to find a job, driven by strong employment growth and falling unemployment rates. The report not only highlights the economic vitality of the Prairie provinces but also provides an invaluable guide for skilled workers and prospective immigrants planning their move to Canada.
08/13/2025
Sorry, your request failed
Please try again
OK